
Receiving and then having to respond to a Cease and Desist letter (C&D) or Letter Before Action (LBA) alleging intellectual property infringement is a high-stress event for any business owner or executive. The demands are often aggressive, the deadlines impossibly short, and the threats of injunctions and unlimited damages are designed to force an immediate capitulation by design.
However, a cease and desist letter is merely the opening gambit in a commercial negotiation or legal dispute. Capitulating to all demands without proper assessment can unnecessarily destroy your brand equity and saddle you with draconian legal undertakings.
This guide outlines the critical first steps, the tactical leverage available to defendants under UK law and how to respond to a cease and desist letter and navigate the dispute.
What is an IP cease and desist letter?
In the UK, before commencing formal litigation in the High Court or the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC), a claimant is required to comply with the Practice Direction on Pre-Action Conduct (aka the pre-action protocol). A C&D letter (or “letter before action”) is the formal mechanism for doing this.
It must set out the details of the alleged infringement, the specific rights relied upon (e.g. registered trade marks, design rights, copyright, etc.) and state the remedies sought after. These remedies will typically request that you stop the infringing activity, sign binding undertakings (which are essentially legal agreements that will determine what you can and can’t do moving forward) and pay damages and legal costs.
How to respond to a cease and desist letter: The “do not panic” rule
In many cases we have seen, the most damaging mistakes are made in the first 48 hours after receiving a C&D letter…
Generally speaking, the below rules of thumb are recommended.
- Do not contact the claimant directly – Any communication (i.e. an apology or attempt to provide an explanation) could be used against you as an admission of liability. All communications are best handled by specialist IP legal support and marked as “without prejudice” where appropriate.
- Do not sign any undertakings – C&D letters almost always include draft legal undertakings. Signing these is a legally binding contract admitting liability and usually severely limiting future commercial freedom. In most cases, signing these to make an issue “go away” is much more damaging to a business than instructing legal support.
- Acknowledge receipt safely – If the deadline is looming (these letters typically include deadlines of 7 or 14 days), your legal representatives will send a neutral acknowledgement of receipt, and include a request for a reasonable extension of time to investigate and respond to the claim. This extension will generally be granted as part of the pre-action engagement sequence.
- Preserve evidence – As it relates to the alleged infringement, implement a document hold. Do not delete emails, design files, web pages, posts, or data. If any proof of evidence being deleted is found later and the claim reaches a Court hearing, this will be heavily penalised by the Court and could undermine the legal position.
Assessing the threat and identifying leverage
Timing is critical, and so is the experience and expertise being applied to the legal question. A specialist IP solicitor has insight into the nuance that generalists don’t and will be able to dissect the claimant’s position for potential weaknesses, disarming the claim.
Unjustified threats
UK intellectual property law contains a unique and highly potent mechanism which prevents those seeking to bully others through groundless claims as a means to damage a competitor’s business.
Under the Trade Marks Act, Patents Act and Registered Designs Act, making an “unjustified threat” of infringement proceedings is a statutory tort.
“We frequently see letters before action drafted by general commercial litigators who do not understand the strict rules around IP threats. If a claimant makes an overly aggressive threat regarding certain IP rights without a solid legal foundation, the tables can quickly turn against them. In such cases we can counter-sue the claimant for the damage caused by the threat itself (whilst typically also dismissing the claim in the first instance). Identifying an unjustified threat is often our strongest leverage in forcing the claimant to drop the matter, or settle favourably with our client.“
Elizabeth Ward, Principal and Founder, Virtuoso Legal
Auditing the claimant’s rights
Before addressing whether you have been infringed, our team will forensically assess if the claimant’s rights are actually valid and enforceable.
Some of the avenues we might explore to do so include:
- Non-use – Has their trade mark been registered for over 5 years? If they haven’t put it to genuine commercial use in the UK during that time (for the classes registered, and the specification claimed), their mark may be vulnerable.
- Prior rights – Did you start using your brand or design before they registered theirs (if the claim is related to a registered right)? In such cases, your prior rights in unregistered design rights and passing off may come into play.
- Invalidity – Is their patent or registered design actually novel, or was it already in the public domain? Is there any potential for trade mark invalidity proceedings?
Calling the bluff on costs
Many C&D letters threaten to issue proceedings in the High Court, explicitly intimidating through the threat of catastrophic unlimited legal costs. For SME and lower-level disputes this is often a tactical bluff.
If the dispute is demonstrably of a lower commercial value, the appropriate venue will be the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC). The IPEC enforces strict costs caps (maximum recoverable costs for a liability trial are £60,000) and limits damages to £500,000. Knowing that the claimant cannot use the threat of unlimited legal fees to bury you fundamentally changes the negotiation dynamic.
Strategic responses and commercial outcomes
- A robust rebuttal – If, through our assessment, we’ve identified that the claimant’s key IP is vulnerable, or your actions do not constitute infringement, we draft a comprehensive response dismantling their claim, often accompanied by a threat to invalidate their IP if they proceed.
- Negotiation, commercial settlement and co-existence – If there is a risk of liability, but the claimant’s business does not directly compete with yours, we can often propose and negotiate a mutually beneficial arrangement in the form of a co-existence agreement. This allows both parties to operate within strictly defined commercial boundaries (e.g. different geographical territories or distinct categories of goods or services).
- Strategic retreat and run-off – If the infringement is clear-cut, the goal then shifts towards damage limitation – in essence making the best of a bad situation for your business. We would then seek to negotiate a “run-off” period, which allows you to sell off existing stock and transition to a new brand in an orderly fashion – avoiding sudden supply chain disruption and minimising damages.
Common questions we’re asked
First and foremost, do not panic. Do not contact the sender directly and avoid making any impulsive admissions. Your instructed legal counsel will typically undertake the following actions. Firstly, they will note the response deadline stated in the letter, and usually request a reasonable extension of these deadlines. Secondly, they will likely encourage you to implement a document preservation exercise – ensuring that all files, code, invoices, sales information and collateral relevant to the claim are preserved. Thirdly, your specialist legal support will begin the process of auditing the claimant’s rights and claim before any formal response is issued.
No. You should never sign undertakings without independent legal advice from an IP solicitor, even in the event that, on the surface, you’re happy to comply. Claimant’s letters before action typically include aggressively drafted undertakings with excessive demands that are typically far beyond what a court would order (i.e. excessive damages, total destruction of valuable stock, onerous disclosure of commercial information and full payment of legal costs).
Under UK law (including Section 21 of the Trade Marks Act 1994, Section 26 of the Patents Act 1977 and the Intellectual Property (Unjustified Threats) Act 2017), an IP owner cannot make groundless threats of legal proceedings against secondary parties or retailers. As a result, claims that are made must be accurate, based on genuine and valid IP rights and not made in bad faith. If an aggrieved party receives an unjustified threat, they can counter-sue the claimant for an injunction restraining the threats, a declaration that the threat is unjustified, and damages for any commercial loss suffered.
Ignoring a formal Letter Before Action (LBA) is highly dangerous. Under the UK Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), parties are legally required to engage in pre-action conduct to resolve disputes without litigation. If you ignore a letter, the claimant can issue High Court or IPEC proceedings without further notice, apply for an emergency interim injunction, and seek adverse cost orders against your business for unreasonable conduct as a result of non-engagement, even if you subsequently defend the claim successfully. Instead, instructing IP legal support to reply without conceding any ground will put you in the best position to avoid disruption to your business.
In the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC), recoverable legal costs for the liability stage of a trial are capped at £60,000, and damages are capped at £500,000. This statutory framework levels the commercial battlefield: deep-pocketed corporate claimants cannot use the threat of unlimited legal fees to force scaling SMEs into surrender (which is something that we often see larger businesses seek to do as a litigation tactic), making early, proportionate commercial settlements far more achievable.
Need immediate advice on how to respond to a cease and desist letter you have received?
Receiving a letter before action or cease and desist for IP can be very intimidating. Deadlines loom and it is critical to not misstep. Our team can help you make the best of your legal position, limiting disruption to your business and even dismissing the claim entirely. Get in touch with our team below.