Passing off vs. trade mark infringement: Protecting unregistered brand goodwill in the UK

Passing off vs trade mark infringement UK — Protecting unregistered brand goodwill and the Classic Trinity

Understanding passing off vs trade mark infringement is critical when it comes to brand protection. For a business, brand equity (the recognition, trust and loyalty tied to a name, logo or “get up”) is a highly valuable commercial asset. However, the legal mechanism to protect that asset depends entirely on whether their brand is formally registered.

While registered trade mark infringement provides a straightforward statutory remedy against copycats, many businesses rely on the common law tort of “passing off” to protect their unregistered rights.

This guide breaks down some of the critical legal and commercial differences in passing off vs trade mark infringement, and outlines the tactical realities of enforcing unregistered rights in the UK Courts.

Trade mark infringement: A statutory shield

As outlined in the Trade Marks Act 1994, a registered trade mark grants you a statutory monopoly over the use of a sign. If a competitor uses an identical or confusingly similar mark for similar goods or services, you can sue for trade mark infringement. You do not need to prove that it was a deliberate act of copying.

The commercial advantage of enforcing infringement of registered trade marks is that it is relatively straightforward to prove. If there is so-called “double identity” (identical mark, identical goods), liability is strict. There is no requirement to prove that the public was actually confused, nor do you need to prove that you have suffered quantifiable financial damage at the first stage. The fact of the registration is all that’s required.

Passing off: Protecting unregistered goodwill

On the other hand, if the business never registered its key brand assets (logo, name, slogan, etc.) as trade marks and a competitor copies the “look and feel” of your packaging (which isn’t registered), you have to rely on the law of passing off.

Passing off does not protect a sign (i.e. name or logo) itself. Instead, it protects the goodwill attached to your business. The fundamental principle is that “nobody has the right to represent their goods as the goods of somebody else.”

The evidentiary marathon: The “classic trinity”

To succeed in a passing off claim, a claimant must prove three elements, famously established in the Jif Lemon case (Reckitt & Colman Products Ltd. v Borden Inc.) This is known as the “classic trinity”.

  1. Goodwill (not just reputation) – The claimant in a passing off case must prove that their business has established goodwill in the UK market. Goodwill is the “attractive force which brings in custom”. Proving goodwill typically involves a large amount of evidence, including (but not limited to) things like: historical sales, information, marketing spend, website analytics, and testimonials that prove the public specifically associates your brand signs or packaging with your specific business.
  2. Misrepresentation – Next, the claimant must prove the defendant made a misrepresentation (intentional or otherwise) to the public, leading the public to believe that their goods or services are yours (or are affiliated with you). To this point, it is not enough to show similarity, but specific evidence that a substantial portion of your buying public has actually been deceived.
  3. Damage – Finally, you must prove that your business has suffered, or is likely to suffer, actual damage as a result of the misrepresentation. This could be hard proof of lost sales, dilution of brand exclusivity or damage to your brand’s reputation if the competitor’s goods are of inferior quality.

The commercial reality: Litigators prefer registered marks

Relying on passing off is often riskier, more time-consuming and expensive than relying on enforcing registered rights.

“A trade mark infringement claim can often be dealt with swiftly in the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC) because the registered right is a matter of public record. Passing off, in comparison, is an evidentiary nightmare! Whilst it may be clear that wrongdoing has occurred, to enforce the right we have to deploy significant time and resources to gather the financial and marketing data to prove goodwill before we then even address the competitor’s actions. The official fee to register and renew a UK trade mark is a fraction of the cost of proving goodwill in a passing off trial. In most cases, clients that we have supported in these kinds of disputes then put themselves in a better position afterwards by securing registered rights.”

Elizabeth Ward, Founder and Principal, Virtuoso Legal

Can you claim both trade mark infringement and passing off?

Yes, and this is often standard practice in IP litigation. If a business holds a registered trade mark, and it is in the best interests of the client, our team will often combine this claim with a statutory trade mark infringement and passing off claim.

If the registered trade mark has limited scope or coverage in its specification, for example, this can provide a more substantive claim. The passing off claim can also serve as a critical safety net, providing the evidence needed to prove the classic trinity is readily available.

How long does it take to establish goodwill?

There is no statutory time limit. In fast-moving consumer markets, massive advertising campaigns can build significant goodwill in a matter of weeks. For a local, niche B2B service, it may take years of steady trading. However, mere trading does not automatically equal goodwill.

Does passing off cover the shape of a product?

Yes, passing off can protect “get-up”, i.e. the overall visual appearance, shape, or packaging of a product (as with the famous Jif Lemon-shaped bottle).

However, proving that the public relies solely on the shape of a product to identify its origin, rather than the brand name written on it, is particularly difficult.

Can a foreign business claim passing off in the UK?

A foreign business can claim passing off in the UK only when they have customers in the UK. Having a global reputation is not enough; the UK courts require proof of actual business generated in the UK jurisdiction and thus evidence of the resulting protectable goodwill in the UK.

Are you trying to stop a copycat or seeking to defend a claim of passing off?

Because passing off relies entirely on the strength of your evidence, early assessment is vital. Contact our specialist team to evaluate your goodwill and discuss the most cost-effective enforcement strategy.